I want to expand on something I posted in my chart patterns entry where I mentioned that I got too heavily involved on Roddick at short odds. Firstly let me say that I don't have a problem getting on something that's short odds, if it represents a good bet / position, then I'm going to take it regardless (though I do drawn the line at backing at 03 or less usually - it's needless effort for little reward). What I did in the Roddick match however, has made a dangerous mental trap much clearer to me, and this weeks trading has been much more fruitful because of this.
I had the realisation that had I not overstaked on Roddick at those odds I would not have felt the urge to mess around with the position later on - cutting my loss, then beginning to trading at a higher frequency without much thought to make back the loss.
This might seem pretty obvious, but the actual nature of the problem has really hit home for me this week. Over-stake past your threshold and you open yourself to the possibility of a problematic market if things don't go perfectly right for you.. and lets face it, how often can you say things go immediately your way as soon as you get on? Not often enough!
This also touches upon a few things in my expect the unexpected entry about acceptance of risk. When you enter a trade you may feel you have accepted it, but if you get in too heavy, you'll quickly find out whether you really did accept it or not when you begin to panic about how quickly the odds are moving against you. This is the true test.
Overtrading is arguably the worst problem a trader faces. It's usually (but not always) caused by a fear of losing. You might think you can grab ticks here and there quickly, or you have a bad position so you will trade lots in order to improve your p/l ratio... Either way, it's usually as a result of not accepting risk in the market place and being fearful of losing.
For me personally I have found this to occur when I began with a position that was too big. It's beyond my pain threshold to lose this amount, I would be very uncomfortable with that loss. Under such circumstances I can freeze and stop thinking until finally I cut the position... normally this is at a market high or low, corresponding with my moment of most intense panic (there's a reason highs and lows are usually spikes or crazy prices that correspond with market panic).
After this has occured, I'm usually rather annoyed to put it mildly and will begin to look for more and more positions to take, perhaps even guess which way things will go, when I get them wrong I cut quickly and look for another, and another. I'm now, overtrading. It doesn't take a genius to see that there's a very high probability I'm going to keep losing more and more money each time, and that it'll take a lucky break to get close to getting out alive.
That's a fairly extreme example, but contrast it to a position I take where I'm actually comfortable with the stake size. An amount that I don't mind losing and that I think is appropriate for the position I'm taking. I'm happy and prepared for this not to go my way because I don't mind losing the bet, I've accepted the risk in the market and the match I'm betting on and most important - the risk of this amount of money.
Mentally I'm secure and calm. There's no panic, or possibility of panic entering my head at any time in this match now that I have staked it properly. I'm free to follow my plan, I know why I entered the trade and I know what reasons would cause me to exit it and I'll act on them - no freezing here.
It's amazing how easily this can go unnoticed. Yes I've known for a very long time that going in heavy at short odds is potential trouble, but the exact reason why has been elusive to me. And it's not just short odds this applies to, it's all odds and bets. If you overstake them beyond an amount you mind losing, then you are opening yourself to all kinds of trouble.
How do you know what the right amount is? Tricky question. It's easy to give answers such as, 2% of your bank, or a specific amount and or some amount specified by the many staking plans out there. I don't disagree that you need to stake things ina technically correct manner, but to get the right size I think has to come from yourself. You know instinctively when the urge rises to tamper with a position (because you are fearful of losing) that you have too big a position. Cut down the size of the position and re-assess comfort levels. When you find the right size, stick with that until your bank has grown enough to facilitate a raising of these comfort thresholds.
The last two weeks have been kind to me, because I've been placing positions where I've been in control and acceptance. And on top of that, I've cut when I had reason to and run the rest of the positions, most of which have won thankfully. I've placed bets with a specific size at various times of the matches and I've stuck to it, it's been a breath of fresh air really... not having to grip the mouse with white knuckles all the time!
Remember this, if the only reason you are cutting your position is because you don't want to lose that amount, you got in too big in the first place. Make sure you stake correctly so that you cut only when there's a real reason to do so.